If you ask Rick Astley for a DVD of the movie Up...

If you ask Rick Astley for a DVD of the movie Up, he won’t give it to you because he’s never gonna give you Up. However, by not giving you Up like you asked for it, he’s letting you down. This is known as the Astley paradox.

This joke is based around a pop culture reference, and also a meme culture reference. To understand the paradox requires the listener to know the lyrics to the song "Never Gonna Give You Up" by Rick Astley. The lyrics state that Rick is "Never gonna give you up. Never gonna let you down, etc." In the first part of the song the jokester assumes that Rick was talking about a DVD of the movie Up when he said NGGYU. This is incorrect - the false assumption is based on a pretty awful pun, however it is also a moderately funny pun.

The second part says that he would let you down, which he explicitly denied that he would do in the lyrics to the song, so he is breaking his word. To call that a paradox is silly because the lyrics to the song were not supposed to be taken as logical statements, but instead as passion fueled ramblings.

To give that paradox a name, and declare it to be "known" makes it seem like people have written about this in a serious way, and that it is such a commonly known paradox that it deserves a name. That is just absurd, and that is why this is so funny.

I must admit, this is the best joke that I have read in a long time. 

As a side note, to make people think about the song NGGYU is known as Rick-Rolling, and it is considered to be a good way to tease people on the internet, and is considered mildly annoying. This might also be a mild form of a Rick-Roll.

Comments

Labels

bar misunderstanding unexpected knock knock Christmas programming definitional bad dad anti-humor talking animals failed expectation political irony black elephant language onomatopoeia Biden deconstruction disability literal math airplane ambiguous grammar lie dark false assumption garden path occupation rude self denigrating canadian internet explorer knowledge mass culture physics slapstick illogical misfortune put-down racist surprise animal bathroom humor contradiction english funny setupless shaggy dog stupid toilet humor alcoholic aptronym black humor board game body humor cat depression dog famous person impulse control insinuation juxtaposition meta nationalist pop culture punchlineless speech problems surprised pikachu Halloween Karen Lord of the Rings archetype breaking behavior dissonance blonde cheese chicken circular confirmation coronavirus covid-19 death deliberate dissonance fake punchline fish hyperbole hypocrite implied punchline inappropriate joke lazy light-bulb mispronounce monday obama obscure old pessimism photoshopped pirate plumber portmanteau repetitive sad but true sarcastic self referential spelling star wars stealth stereotype suspended disbelief talking food technology troll untellable violence weird whiplash work your mother Disney Pavlov Perl accent accident adage advertisement allusion anakin skywalker anti-pun audience participation bald bash biology booger call and response chemistry clown context covid current events date dated delusion difference doge drug duck electrician emo evil cat face bomb faces false dichotomy fantasy fat fear fickle forgetful fourth wall breaking garbage man generational gesture gif gorillas greedy harry potter hippie historical history idiom immature insultnsult jargon lettuce library linguistic long macabre made up words media mental illness mexico mistake mondegreen name-calling nazi numbers one-liner paradox pedantic pokemon poker face prank call pretentious prison protests punctuation purple prose rap reverse roll safe science sickness spiderman spoonerism straight man subversion suicide surreal swear swearing talking objects thinker true typo unpronounceable unstated vegan visual winter work humor written only wrong zoo
Show more

More jokes